1                1/229 a              R1   EF+         1863 Our Country. (<25)

2                1/391 a              R1   EF+         Trace Red.  1863 IOU 1 Cent. (<25)

3                1/436 a              R5   VF+         Scarce United Country reverse die. (25-50)

4                5/288 a              R2   EF+         God Protect The Union . (25-50)

5                6/268 a              R1   AU          Trace Red.  1863 Union For Ever. (25-50)

6                6A/269 a           R4   VF           Scarce obverse die and variety. (25-50)

7                7/313 a              R2   AU          From very rusted obverse die with light scratches around date.  Underrated variety, recently changed from R6 probably in error. (25-50)

8                7B/315 a            R7   FINE+     Late die state.  Rare obverse die. (25-50)

9                8A/317 a           R2   EF           1863 Army & Navy. (<25)

10              8B/309 a            R1   VF+         Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy. (<25)

11              8C/313 a            R3   EF           Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy.  Very scarce obverse die. (25-50)

012                                                                       013                                                                      043

14              9/405 a              R6   VF+         The Constitution Must  And Shall Be Preserved.  Very scarce Indiana Primitive in grades above VF. (100-150)

15            11/298 a             R1   EF+         1863 Army & Navy. (<25)

16            13/297 a             R2   AU          1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

17            16/300 a             R3   AU          20% Red.  1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

18            16/301 a             R4   AU          1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

19            17/388 a             R2   VF           Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. (<25)

20            18/300 a             R2   AU          1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

21            19/396 a             R2   EF           Well struck for variety.  Wilson 's Medal 1863. (<25)

22            20/303 a             R3   EF+         1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

23            22/418 a             R3   EF+         1863 Peace Forever with NORTH and SOUTH shaking hands. (25-50)

24            23/306 a             R2   VF           1863 Army & Navy. (<25)

25            25/418 a             R4   EF+         Trace Red.  1863 Peace Forever with NORTH and SOUTH shaking hands. (50-75)

26            26/418 b             R6   EF           1863 Peace Forever with NORTH and SOUTH shaking hands. (50-75)

27            28/303 a             R2   AU+        20% Red.  Liberty Head 1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

28            29/303 a             R2   VF           Error struck off center 20%.  Civil War tokens are rarely seen this far off center.  1863 Army & Navy. (50-75)

29            32/275 a             R6   VF           With a few light marks.  1863 Our Card. (25-50)

30            34/276 a             R6   EF           Union 1863 Our Card.  Rarity recently changed from R8 to R6. (50-75)

31            34/277 a             R3   FINE+     A bit dark.  1863 Union Our Card. (<25)

32            36/340 a             R2   EF+         Liberty and No Slavery. (50-75)

33            36/340 a             R2   MS63         10% Red.  Liberty and No Slavery.  In a NGC holder graded MS63 BN. (100-150)

34            37/434 a             R1   EF+         Trace Red.  For Public Accommodation 1863 United States Copper. (<25)

35            37/434 d             R8   MS62      60% Bright struck with some light planchet file marks as often seen on this composition.  For Public Accommodation 1863 United States Copper struck in Copper Nickel.  Very rare variety, the first I have seen offered.  In a NGC holder graded MS61. (300-400)

36            41/337 a             R2   EF           1863 Our Navy. (<25)

37            42/336 a             R4   MS62      Trace Red.  Our Navy 1864 Liberty Cap.  Very scarce this nice.  In a NGC holder graded MS63 RB. (100-150)

38            43/287 a             R4   EF           Millions For Defense Not One Cent For The Widows 1863.  Scarce reverse die with stars at base of wreath, obverse signed L. Leightweis. (50-75)

39            45/332 a             R1   MS62      30% Red.  Liberty 1863 Our Army.  An AU+ brought $36.30 in my March 2008 sale. (50-75)

40            46/335 a             R2   EF           Trace Red.  Liberty 1864 Our Army. (<25)

41            46/339 a             R1   AU          Liberty 1864 with shield. (25-50)

42            47/332 a             R1   AU          Normal cud and die break.  Liberty 1864 Our Army. (25-50)

43    P      47/332 ao           R9   EF           Struck over Patriotic token 343/49.  A rare and very visual variety with a large and small date side by side on the obverse. (500-750)

44            48/299 a             R1   EF+         United We Stand Divided We Fall 1863. (25-50)

45            49/343 a             R1   EF           Union For Ever 1864. (<25)

46            50/179 a             R8   VF+         Reverse cud at center as usual for this die combination.  Rare variety only sixth example I have seen offered.  A VF realized $84.44 in my July 2006 sale. (100-150)

47            51/333 a             R6   EF           With a few light marks.  Rare and underrated reverse die.  Just the seventh example I have recorded all EF and below.  Another EF with a verdigris stain brought $338.38 in my July 2006 sale. (400-500)

48            54/335 b             R7   MS63      40% Bright.  Liberty Our Army struck in Brass.  Slightly nicer than the MS62 that realized $207.77 in my July 2007 auction.  In a NGC holder graded MS64. (300-400)

49            55/162 a             R1   EF+         1864 Indian Princess Our Army. (25-50)

50    P      56/229 a             R7   MS62      Trace Red and a bit weakly struck.  Scarce obverse die and rare variety.  An MS63 brought $347.60 in my July 2006 sale. (300-400)

51            56/229 e             R7   MS63      40% Bright.  1864 Our Country struck in White Metal. In a NGC holder graded MS63. (300-400)

52            58/439 a             R3   VG+        Popular Odd Fellows reverse die.  A FINE+ brought $66 in my December 2008 auction. (25-50)

53            61/198 a             R3   EF           1863 Indian Head with eagle on shield. (25-50)

54            62/367 a             R3   VF           1863 Not One Cent. (<25)

55            63/366 a             R1   VF           1863 Not One Cent.  With interesting reverse die break as usual. (<25)

56            63/443 a             R2   MS63      1863 Indian Head New York .  Very scarce this nice, a AU+ brought $38.50 in my December 2000 sale. (50-75)

57            64/362 a             R4   EF           Unusually well struck for this scarce token with strong date.  A similar example brought $72.93 in my March 2008 sale. (50-75)

58            68/198 a             R4   EF           Tiny rim clip and residue traces. (25-50)

59            68A/371 a          R3   VF+         1863 Not One Cent. (25-50)

60            73/ 84 a              R6   FINE+     Residue traces.  Rare double headed Indian Head.  A FINE+ sold for $167.20 in my May 2001 auction. (150-200)

61            73/525 a             R4   VF+         Retoned.  $100 Bounty, Pensions, Back Pay & C. Collected & Cashed.  Two scarce Patriotic. (50-75)

62            76/523 a             R4   VF           With small stain.  1864 Grindstone Flagging & Building Stones.  Two very scarce dies. (100-150)

63            78/330 a             R4   AU+        10% Red.  Two scarce dies, particularly this nice. (75-100)

64            79/351 a             R1   EF           Liberty 1863 with crossed cannons. (<25)

65            80/351 a             R3   AU+        10% Red.  1863 Indian Head with cannons, flags and drum. (25-50)

66            82/352A a          R2   AU+        20% Red.  1863 Indian Head with cannons, flags and drum. (25-50)

67            83/264 a             R5   EF+         With nice even strike.  Pay The Bearer One Cent 1863.  In a NGC holder graded AU55 BN. (100-150)

050                                                                       068                                                                      073

68    P      85/431 a             R8   VF           A choice example of this rare obverse die, much nicer than usual.  A similar EF brought $450 in my December 2006 sale. (500-750)

69            86/357 a             R2   AU          Late die state struck from clashed dies with interesting obverse die cracks. (25-50)

70            88/361 a             R3   AU          Very late obverse die state as usual with weak date and fuzzy detail.  The reverse is strong but struck from a clashed die from a different die combination.  Interesting and scarce patriotic dies. (25-50)

71            90/364 a             R1   VF+         1863 Not One Cent with tiny eagle's head on reverse. (<25)

72            93/394 a             R3   AU+        Weak obverse date as usual.  McClellan Medal For One Cent. (25-50)

73    P      96/116 b             R8   MS62      10% Bright slightly weak.  Two very scarce dies.  Just the fourth example I have seen offered.  A similar example with the same weakness brought $594 in my March 2002 sale. (1,000-1,500)

75            99/292 a             R3   VF           Union And Liberty 1863 One Country. (25-50)

074                                                                       076                                                                      084

76    P      100/341 a            R7   MS63      50% Red.  United We Stand 1863 Union For Ever.  Very scarce obverse die. (300-400)

77            103/375 a            R4   VF           Indian Head 1863 Not One Cent.  Much nicer than normally seen. (25-50)

78            105/355 a            R3   EF           George Washington in Star Not One Cent. (25-50)

79            111/340 a            R3   VF           1863 George Washington with shield, flags and a Liberty cap. (<25)

80            112/396 a            R1   VF           1863 George Washington with Wilson 's Medal reverse. (<25)

81            117/420 a            R1   VF           With just a tiny cud at obverse rim.  1863 George Washington Exchange. (<25)

82            117/420 b            R4   VF           1863 George Washington Exchange struck in Brass. (25-50)

83            123/0 f                 R5   MS63      20% Bright.  A restrike struck in Silver from an original die with blank reverse.  George Washington in a large Capitol Plastic holder stating it was struck from the original die and 350 were struck.  An MS62 brought $176 in my July 2009 sale. (200-300)

84    P      124/201 j             R7   MS62      30% Bright well struck and nicely toned.  Rare 1864 Abraham Lincoln obverse die with Our Union reverse struck in German Silver.  In a NGC holder graded MS62. (750-1,000)

85            126/295 d            R6   FINE+     Lincoln The Right Man In The Right Place 1864 struck in Copper Nickel. (100-150)

86            127/201 a            R4   AU+        Trace Red quite weakly struck at centers as usual for this die combination.  Lincoln 1864 / Our Union shield. (150-200)

87            127/248 b            R3   EF+         Trace Bright.  Lincoln 1864 OK. (75-100)

088                                                                           090                                                                             104

88    P      129/282 e            R9   MS60      50% Bright with a couple tiny reverse rim nicks.  Abraham Lincoln 1864 with a crude rubber necking eagle struck in White Metal.  Very rare variety and reverse die, just the ninth I have seen offered for all the thirteen die combinations and compositions listed in Fuld.  From the Henry South collection ex. Kirtley September 1993. (1,000-1,500)

089                                                                                                             100

89    P      131/217 a            R8   MS63      60% Red and Proof Like.  1864 Abraham Lincoln with Long May It Wave flag struck in Copper.  Rare obverse die, another Copper example realized $850 in my March 2003 sale.  In a NGC holder graded MS63 RB PL. (1,500-2,000)

91            132/149 a            R5   EF           Retoned.  For President Abraham Lincoln / For Vice President Andrew Johnson.  Popular token signed RL on each side for the maker Robert Lovett Jr. of Philadelphia .  A VF realized $165 in my July 2007 auction. (150-200)

92            133/458 b            R6   EF+         10% Bright well struck and holed as usual.  Lincoln and Liberty Good For Another Heat with ax in log.  An EF brought $176 in my July 2007 sale. (150-200)

93            135/441 a            R2   AU          Trace Red with normal weakness opposite Jackson 's head.  For Our Country A Common Cause. (<25)

94            136/397 a            R1   AU          Trace Red with a few light linear obverse flaws.  Andrew Jackson with Beware 1863 with coiled snake on reverse. (25-50)

95            137/395 a            R1   VF+         Tiny clip with slightly weak reverse as usual.  Andrew Jackson This Medal Price One Cent. (<25)

96            138/255 a            R2   EF+         George McClellan Knickerbocker Currency. (25-50)

97            141/307 a            R1   EF           Crude General George B. McClellan Army & Navy. (25-50)

98            143/261 a            R1   AU          This Medal Of G. B. McClellan Price One Cent. (25-50)

99            143/261 ap g       R8   EF           Copper plated lead with 30% of original plating remaining, surfaces rough as usual.  An EF+ that was less rough brought $137.50 in my July 2009 auction. (100-150)

100  P      147/227 fp          R6   VF+         With 10% of original Silver plating remaining.  Popular Am I Ready 1861 pilgrim token.  This plated version has been removed from the current book and replaced by a footnote.  This is the normal composition for this die combination, over 60% by my count.  It is very hard to find a Brass example that isn't very worn or still has traces of silvering.  Ex. Dennis Haskett Collection. (300-400)

101          153/0 ao              R7   MS63      30% Red.  Rare Franklin die struck over the obverse of an 1850 Large Cent.  The cent is AU+ with 20% Red.  One of the nicest example I can recall seeing.  Ex. Larkin Wilson and New York Public Library. (750-1,000)

102          154/218 a            R6   VF           Retoned.  Stephen Douglas with Naked Amazon reverse.  A VF realized $148.50 in my March 2008 auction. (100-150)

103          155/400 a            R4   FINE+     Scarce Indiana Primitive die combination, encountered about half as frequently as the following. (75-100)

104  P      155/431 a            R4   AU+        Trace Red.  Very nice Indiana Primitive with Value Me As You Peas reverse.  An EF+ realized $150 in my December 2008 auction. (200-300)

105          165/400 a            R5   EF           Indiana Primitive version of the Union shield die 163 although Union isn't so much spelled out on the shield as it is represented by a series of thick vertical lines.  Another EF brought $130 in my last sale. (100-150)

106          167/318 a            R5   EF           But quite porous.  Two scarce dies. (25-50)

107          168/311 a            R1   VF           Cannon and cannon balls 1863 Army & Navy. (25-50)

108          169/213 a            R2   VF           Popular Peace Maker cannon 1863. (25-50)

109          174/272 a            R1   EF           First In War First In Peace 1863 with Washington on horseback. (<25)

110          175/232 a            R6   F/VF        Weak date as usual.  Very scarce Indiana Primitive reverse die.  From my April 1996 auction where it brought $23.10. (50-75)

111          175/232 a            R6   AU+        Well struck for variety but date weak as usual.  Very scarce Indiana Primitive reverse die.  An AU brought $175 in my last sale. (200-300)

112          175/400 a            R3   MS60      Trace Red very well struck and centered with a small well hidden scratch between the horses two front legs.  A nice example of the so-called shitting horse (AKA 175C) Indiana Primitive.  A choice AU brought $165 in my March 2008 sale. (150-200)

113          175/400 a            R3   AU+        Well struck and centered.  Another nice example of the so-called shitting horse Indiana Primitive. (150-200)

114          175/400 a            R3   VF           Indiana Primitive, this horse is under control. (25-50)

115          175/401 a            R5   EF+         With small edge dent. The Union Must and Shall be Preserved - Jackson . (25-50)

116          175/401 a            R5   EF+         The Union Must and Shall be Preserved - Jackson . (75-100)

117          175/401 a            R5   MS62      Sharp strike with just one weak letter on reverse.  First In Peace First In War 1863 The Union Must and Shall be Preserved - Jackson .  In a NGC holder graded MS62 BN.  Another NGC MS62 sold for $330 in my March 2008 auction. (400-500)

118          175/403 a            R4   VG+        Well worn with no problems except normal weak date. (<25)

119          176/271 a            R1   AU          20% Red.  First In Peace, First In War 1863 Union For Ever. (25-50)

120          176/271 j             R7   EF           First In Peace, First In War 1863 Union For Ever struck in German Silver.  Rare variety, just the third I have seen offered. (100-150)

121          177/271 a            R4   EF+         First In Peace, First In War 1863 Union For Ever.  Scarce Obverse die. Ex. Henry South. (25-50)

122          180/341 a            R1   VF           Missing obverse motto with very weak reverse as usual. (<25)

123          189/389 a            R1   VF+         Union flags 1863 with Star of David reverse. (<25)

124          191/443 a            R1   AU          Trace Red a bit weakly struck.  Pro Bono Publico 1863 New York . (<25)

125          195/378 a            R3   AU          With interesting obverse die cracks. (25-50)

126          196/355 a            R3   EF+         10% Red.  Eagle on Shield with ribbon 1863 Not One Cent. (25-50)

127          197/380 a            R2   VF           United States of America 1863 with eagle on shield. (<25)

128          202/434 a            R1   EF+         Tradesmen's Currency. (<25)

129          203/413 a            R3   EF           The Flag Of Our Union 1863.  Scarce obverse die. (25-50)

130          204/413 a            R5   EF           Rare single use obverse die, only the ninth example I have seen offered.  Another EF realized $146 in my July 2009 sale in active bidding. (100-150)

132          207/324 a            R7   AU+        10% Red.  Rare die combination, an EF brought $93.50 in my December 2000 auction.  From the Henry South collection. (150-200)

133          207/412 a            R3   EF           Scarce variety. (25-50)

134  P      209/414 ao          R10 VF           With a few light marks.  Struck over Straight's Elephantine Shoe Store, Albany New York store card NY 10F-1a and listed as Unique.  Most easily visible on the reverse is the obverse of the store card including portions of the Elephant..  Ex. Jon Harris collection. (400-500)

135          211/400 a            R4   EF           Well struck and nicely centered.  The Indiana Primitive version of The Flag Of Our Union. (75-100)

136          223/325 b            R3   EF+         20% Bright.  The Federal Union Must And Shall Be Preserved struck in Brass.  Very scarce variety. (25-50)

131                                                                       134                                                                       137

137  P      225/225 Inc a      R9   EF           Reverse has light stains.  Full Mirror Brockage mint error.  A rare type and just the second example I have recorded of this variety. (500-750)

138          229/359 a            R9   MS62      Reverse die slightly off center.  Rare Our Country Not One Cent die variety struck in Copper.  Just the third I have seen offered, an Uncirculated example with obverse spots brought $176 in my August 1994 sale. (400-500)

139          230/352B a          R2   EF+         Our Country with crossed Union cannons. (<25)

140          231/352A a         R1   EF+         Our Country with crossed Union cannons. (<25)

141          234/431 a            R6   EF+         Trace Red with a linear obverse planchet flaw from 2 to 6 o'clock .  Indiana Primitive version of Scovill's 233 die, the main difference is that this one is actually labeled Capitol.  The only Patriotic use of this obverse die. (75-100)

142          234/431 a            R6   VF           Well struck and centered for the variety.  Capital Building Value Me As You Please. (100-150)

143  P      234/431 a            R6   AU+        Tiny rim clip.  1863 Capital Building Value Me As You Please.  Quite rare in high grade, one of just five example I have recorded above EF.  Another AU+ with 30% red brought $515 in my last sale. (400-500)

144          235/269 a            R2   VF+         Liberty 1863 Union For Ever. (25-50)

145          236/426 a            R1   EF+         Liberty 1863 Union . (<25)

146          237/423 a            R1   MS63      60% Red.  Our Little Monitor 1863.  An AU with 30% Red brought $121 in my July 2007 auction. (150-200)

147          238/402 a            R4   EF           Well struck with some light marks and residue traces.  The Indiana Primitive version of Our Little Monitor.  Very scarce obverse and reverse die. (150-200)

143                                                                       148                                                                       166

148  P      238/405 a            R3   MS63      10% Red with large straight clip.  Scarce Indiana Primitive Our Little Monitor  Just the second Uncirculated example I have seen offered.  A VF brought $202.56 in my March 2008 sale. (500-750)

149          239/421 a            R3   MS62      10% Red. Our Little Monitor 1863.  Rare in Uncirculated, just the fifth I have seen offered. (150-200)

150          240/337 a            R1   EF+         Trace Red.  1863 Our Navy Monitor. (50-75)

151          240/341 a            R1   EF           1863 Monitor Union For Ever. (50-75)

152          241/336 a            R1   AU          1864 Monitor Our Navy. (75-100)

153          243/378 a            R3   EF+         Erinnerung An 1863 Not One Cent signed L. Roloff. (25-50)

154          244/291 a            R2   EF           Remembrance Of 1863 One Country. (<25)

155          245/375A a         R3   EF           Obverse planchet flaw.  Remembrance Of 1863 Not One Cent 1863.  Very scarce obverse die. (50-75)

156          248/271 a            R4   VF           OK Union For Ever.  Very scarce die combination. (25-50)

157          248/432 a            R3   EF+         Trace Red.  OK No Compromise With Traitors. (50-75)

158          250/437 a            R5   VF+         Well struck and nicely centered.  Popular North Star and Argyle Stocking token in much nicer than normally seen. (100-150)

159          252/271 b            R5   VF           Reverse a bit weak as usual.  Masonic square and compass Union For Ever. (50-75)

160          254/255 a            R1   MS62      30% Red.  Money Makes The Mare Go 1863 Knickerbocker Currency. (50-75)

161          255/390 a            R1   EF           Knickerbocker Currency. (<25)

162          256/433 a            R3   MS63      20% Red.  Horrors of War Blessings of Peace.  Always popular, a VF brought $44 in my March 2008 sale. (100-150)

163          257/311 a            R3   EF           Popular Land and Sea token featuring a marching soldier brandishing sword with tiny Monitor ship in the background. (50-75)

164          258/446 a            R3   VF           1863 Trade And Commerce with sailing ship. (20-35)

165          259/445 a            R2   EF           Coppers 20% Premium Trade And Commerce with sailing ship. (25-50)

166  P      260/447 d            R8   MS62      60% Bright.  Constitution 1861 Concession Before Secession struck in Copper Nickel.  A similar example sold for $526.50 in my October 2002 auction.  Ex, Dennis Haskett collection. (500-750)

167          285/383 a            R7   VF           Slightly porous with residues.  Two rare single use Patriotic dies from the Hillsdale Michigan die sinker Gleason.  An EF with verdigris spots brought $605 in my March 2008 sale. (200-300)

168          299/350 a            R2   MS63      10% Red.  Drum, Flags and Crossed Canons Army & Navy. (50-75)

169          299/350 b            R7   MS64      20% Bright.  Drum, Flags and Crossed Canons Army & Navy struck in Brass.  In a NGC holder graded MS64. (300-400)

170          337/350 d            R7   MS62      30% Bright struck in Copper Nickel.  An MS62 realized $231 in my March 2008 sale.  Ex. Larkin Wilson B&M 1996. (200-300)

171  P      349/477 e            R9   VF+         With a few light marks.  Procese with 1864 Cannons and Flags struck in White Metal.  Struck on a very thick planchet, as are all examples of this variety.  An AU also with light marks brought $477 in my October 2001 auction. (500-750)

172          390/434 a            R3   AU          20% Red.  IOU 1 Pure Copper Cent United States Copper. (25-50)

171                                                                       173                                                                       174

173  P      427/472 j             R8   MS62      40% Bright and well struck.  East Boston 1837 Union 1863 struck in German Silver.  Rare reverse die and very rare obverse die. (2,000-3,000)

174  P      427/480A b         R9   EF           With oddly counterstamped reverse as is at least one other example of this variety.  The counterstamp consists of a series of parallel and one perpendicular lines covering two thirds of reverse along with BLOOD / HEAT with the D running mostly off the planchet.  Union C 1863 with Eureka Good For 10.  Two rare dies particularly the reverse.  This die combination often comes with similar counterstamps although this seems to be the most complete, see my sales August 1997 and December 2000. (500-750)

175          449/471 a            R2   EF           United We Stand Divided We Fall.  Underrated variety, much scarcer than the following. (25-50)

176          450/471 a            R1   VF+         United We Stand Divided We Fall. (<25)

177  P      451B/532 b         R9   EF           Two very rare and newly listed Patriotic dies.  With the obverse and reverse are the Fuld plate tokens.  This is still the only public offering of this variety I have seen since first being listed in 1993.  From the Henry South collection from my October 1999 sale where it realized $1,650. (2,000-3,000)

177                                                                   178                                                                             180

179          500/505 b            R8   AU          30% Bright with dark residues. McDONOUGH within wreath with Eagle. Delisted as a Civil War token and thought to be a English game counter honoring heroes of the War of 1812, although a couple appear to be misspelled. In this case Thomas MacDonough who defeated the British on Lake Champlain . A competing theory hold that they are actually Philadelphia store cards from the late 1850's to early 1860's, time may tell the whole story. Or maybe they are all towns in Georgia . From my October 1999 sale. (150-200))

180  P      506/510 a            R8   MS62      30% Red.  Abraham Lincoln / Stephen Douglas.  Rare and popular Lincoln die, just the second example of this variety I have seen offered. (1,000-1,500)

181  P      508/510A a         R8   MS63      60% Red.  John Breckinridge / Presidents House struck in Copper.  Slightly nicer than the example that brought $743.60 in my December 2006 sale. (1,000-1,500)

181                                                                               182

183  P      510/510A a         R8   MS63      70% Red.  Stephen A. Douglas / Presidents House struck in Copper.  Just the second Uncirculated example I have seen offered. (750-1,000)

183                                                                               184

184  P      511/519 a            R8   MS63      10% Red.  The Wealth of the South Rice Tobacco Sugar Cotton with blank reverse die struck in copper.  Very rare, just the second I have seen offered. (1,000-1,500)

185  P      520/521 a            R7   EF           Tiny clip, normal uneven strike, some light marks and very light reverse stain.  Much nicer than it sounds and fairly typical of this crude Escherich token.  Liberty 1860 Copper Mine Token. Another EF with clip, slightly uneven strike and short light scratches brought $513 in my March 2002 sale. Ex. Rich Hartzog collection. (400-500)

185                                                                         186

187          IL Q-10 C           R6   EF           S. Whited & Co. Sutlers, 97th Illinois Volunteers Good For 10 Cent 1862.  Very scarce this nice, normally only seen in lower grades, just the second example in EF or better I have seen offered. (300-400)  

188

188  P      IL N- 5 B            R8   VF+         With a couple of light reverse scratches on a somewhat irregular (hand trimmed?) planchet.  I. August 84th Regiment Illinois Volunteers.  Rare Sutler, just the third I have seen offered. (750-1,000)

189  P      IN D-10 B           R9   VF+         Sutler Check 16th Indiana Volunteers.  Very rare sutler just the third I have seen offered. (750-1,000)

189                                                                       190                                                                       191

190  P      IN F-5 C             R8   VF           A bit wavy as is fairly common with these thin brass planchets.  J. K. Alexander Sutler 33rd Indiana Regiment.  Rare sutler from a very scarce state.  A VF+ brought $1,062.60 in my July 2007 auction. (500-750)

191  P      KY A-25 C         R8   EF           Reverse punch mark at 12 o'clock that pushes up on the obverse.  21st Kentucky Volunteer Infantry 1863.  Rare state for sutler, the first for this variety and just the fifth from this Sutler I have seen offered. (500-750)

192  P      MI A-25 B          R7   VF           J. A. Leggat Sutler 3d. Mich. Cavalry.  Very scarce state for Sutlers. (500-750)

192                                                                      193                                                                            196

193  P      NY E- 5 B           R9   VF           G. H. Benedict was a sutler for the 13th New York Heavy Artillery.  Rare sutler. (750-1,000)

194          OH G- 5 B          R7   EF           Sharp with some light hairlines, struck with incused reverse on a Brass planchet.  5th Regiment Ohio Volunteers. (400-500)

195          OH  W-50 Bb     R7   VF           Tiny clip and a few light marks.  M. Sullivan Sutler 55 Regiment Ohio Volunteer Militia.  Ex. PCAC March 1999. (300-400)

196  P      OH AC-25 B      R8   EF           Wm. W. Drennan 64th Regiment Ohio Volunteers.  Rare Sutler, just the fourth example I have seen offered from all denominations combined.  This is the Schenkman plate specimen. (750-1,000)

197  P      VA E- 5 B           R7   VF           With a number of small dents and digs.  M. Ezekiel 3rd Virginia Regiment.  Rare state..  From B&M's October 1999 sale. (500-750)

197                                                                               198

198  P      WI B-10 Ba         R7   VF           Small patch of short obverse scratches.  Sid Wright Sutlers Store, 11th Regiment Wisconsin Volunteers.  Very rare state, one of just eight examples from all varieties I have seen offered.  From one of my web site price lists. (750-1,000)

199          NL  L-10 B         R7   AU          10% Bright.  H. V. Keep Redeemable In US Currency.  According to my data base this is the scarcest of the four R7 denominations from this sutler.  Ex. E. Rosen PCAC, Hayden web site November 2005 at $600. (750-1,000)

200          NL  M-50 C        R8   AU          Tiny planchet clip.  Simmonds Battery , J. M. Kerr Sutler.  This Sutler is now attributed to Kentucky . (500-750)  

201

201          NL  Q-10 B         R8   EF           R. R. Landon Sutler's Store 1st Regiment USMF.  A VF example brought $550 in my December 2005 auction. (500-750)